Kosher Community Heros

No, this isn’t a photo of the living quarters of undocumented Latin@ workers crammed into the basement of a Postville meat processing plant — but the temporary residence of “over 100 Bochurim [Rabbi Moshe Rubaskin has been hosting] in his home for the month of Tishrai.”

The plant, of course, is referring to the Rubashkins’ Agriprocessors slaughterhouse and packaging plant, the largest kosher beef producer in the U.S., which received 250 noncompliance citations for food safety from the USDA in 2006, the source of two Class I recalls in the past 9 months, as compared to 34 recalls in all of 2006 for the entire beef, poultry and egg industry.

And the man: Rabbi Moshe Rubashkin, convicted criminal and probable felon, who spent the Chagim celebrating with hundreds of community members and politicians, despite a recent indictment by a federal grand jury for toxic waste dumping at the site of his former Montex textile plant in Allentown, PA.

A local paper, the Morning Call, has more on the nature of the crime(s) of Rabbi Moshe Rubashkin, who is the brother of Agriprocessors’ president Sholom Rubaskin, and Moshe’s son Sholom Rubaskin– illegally storing hazardous waste on the site of their former textile plant, lying about it, followed by several fires (of unknown but suspicious origin) started at the plant, and over $400,000 in unpaid taxes. The city of Allentown is now left with the pleasant task of making redevelopment decisions for this 5 acre property contaminated by toxic waste dumping and burning, located next to Good Sheperd Rehabilitation hospital and residential areas. 

By Sept 17th, the father-son duo were free on $250,000 bail, and by Sept 30th they were celebrating in their Sukkah with NY State Senator Eric Adams, City Councilwoman Letitia James and State Assemblyman Karim Camara and many members of the Crown Heights Community, where Moshe Rubashkin is the Chairman of the Jewish Community Council. When Rabbi Moshe was elected to that position, he had just finished a 15 month prison sentence for writing bad checks from Montex, which came on the heels of a fine for denying workers’ workers compensation pay….and the list goes on…

Perhaps we may be able to rely on Failed Messiah, and the new Eye on Agriprocessors website by UFCW (United Food and Commercial Workers) union to monitor violations of food and worker safetyat the Rubashkin’s Agriprocessors plant in Postville, IA, the subject of many recent violations, but how do we know what other shenanigans and illegal misdeeds the fugitive family are up to?

Should they be continue to be heralded as community leaders by politicans and clergy alike?

Shouldn’t there be some accountability among the Jewish community (or the community of Crown Heights for the many violations of federal and state law, not to mention Jewish law, that they have committed?

Interestingly, the UFCW website says:

The UFCW believes that the majority of U.S. kosher meat producers maintain high quality food safety standards, and that Agriprocessors’ track record should not be taken as a reflection of the industry as a whole.

While meatpacking and processing tend to be some of the most exploitive and unsafe institutions and workplaces in all of American industry, we are lucky that some of the additional injustices present at Agriprocessors have not been generalized to the entire kosher meat industry.

If the free market is supposed to enable consumers to “vote with their pocketbooks,” why is the Jewish community not taking a stand against this kind of business owner?

How much longer will this good will last if the Jewish community does not take a stand on some of these issues, with their pocketbooks, pens or any other tools?

Print This Post Print This Post

9 Responses to “Kosher Community Heros”

  1. chillul Who? Says:

    “How much longer will this good will last if the Jewish community does not take a stand on some of these issues, with their pocketbooks, pens or any other tools?”

    I’m not optimistic.

  2. chillul Who? Says:

    I’m not optimistic.

  3. Rabbi Shmuel Says:

    Imagine if tsimmes maker had to post under his/her own name

  4. Gersh Says:

    Um…she does. Try clicking “Aliza Wasserman” on the right side of the page.

  5. Rabbi Shmuel Says:

    Gee why didn’t I think of that

  6. Gersh Says:

    Because you’re not as smart as I am.

  7. Rabbi Shmuel Says:

    you got me there Gersh! I’ll have to wake up earlier to best one of your ilk.

    BTW what is the relevance of the entire post other than an anti orthodox rave? what does the photo represent? so some bochrim stayed with rubashkin for the chagim? so?nu? they don’t mind the cramped accommodations – why should it bother any of you? If it were a Phish concert you’d sleep in the mud for weeks to get tix so why fault them for squeezing in to be where they want to be? and the intentional straw man segue to Agriprocessors – that’s essentially just a cheap shot – ms. tsimmes (or gersh for that matter)- how much time did you spend in Postville? I thought so.

  8. aliza Says:

    Rabbi Shmuel,

    I appreciate your concern for my usage of sensationalized journalism -it was kind of an experiment with regard to the photo at the beginning of the article. I’d be interested to hear other’s comments on the success (or failure) of this tactic.

    With regard to the photograph, it’s kind of a funny one and doesn’t represent anything particularly negative. I was not saying that this is actually what the living quarters of any workers in Postville actually look like, but based on reports of other labor conditions there (and among other employers utilizing undocumented workers) I wouldn’t be surprised if it did.

    To me, the fact that this guy was elected as a community leader despite public knowledge of all of these past and current wrong-doings is a problem, both for society and for the Jewish community.

    I don’t think it’s an anti-orthodox rant at all- we should be holding our selves to a higher standard.
    The entire issue represents a problem – a disconnect between halacha of mitzvot ben adam l’makom and ben adam l’chavero- business ethics. It’s not a critique of the men that are staying in that room, but the fact that this represents the celebration of a criminal, that all of these people are choosing to celebrate the chagim with him, despite all of these illegal and unethical business practices. Similar problems have been present with regard to Agriprocessors- and personally, as someone concerned about environmental and oocupational health, the Montex issues alone are significant, but also are connected with problems with our food system.

    And for the record, I’ve never been a fan of Phish- I don’t even know any of their songs. Thanks for your thoughts.

Leave a Reply



Advertise on The Jew & The Carrot