Mandel

Ethics of a Jewish Carnivore: In Search of the Ideal Steak

Thanks to Hazon’s friend, Lindsey Paige Savoie, for this guest post.

steak.jpgI eat meat. When I first said those three little words to Sabrina, her response was, ‘whoa.’ She didn’t gasp because I eat meat. She could hear the fear in my voice when I said it. Why should I be ashamed to eat meat?

I grew up in Omaha, Nebraska – land of cows. We ate meat daily. Friday night was especially noteworthy as we gathered at my grandparents for the rarest of all meats. I don’t mean hard to find. I mean purple, raw, rare. Now I know why my dad preferred the end cuts.

Summer camp and youth group conventions opened my eyes to new ideas including the notion of becoming a vegetarian. I went through a teenage phase (as my parents called it) of not eating meat or fish. After a few years, I slowly and at times secretly went back to eating meat.

Years later, I still struggle with how, when and where to eat meat. Due to my work in Jewish environmental education and my petsitting business, eating meat is a challenge both socially and mentally. How do I preach environmental values and eat a hamburger? How do I care for animals on a daily basis and then prepare a different type of animal for dinner?

So, where has my journey led me? As I learn more and more about the meat industry and food processing in general, I feel cheated of so much information as a child and still as an adult. Where does my food come from?

One of my best discoveries in recent years has been CSA (Community-Supported Agriculture) programs. Along with weekly deliveries of fresh vegetables and fruit, our family now gets eggs, chicken and even our traditional Thanksgiving Day turkey from our CSA farm, Good Fortune Farms. Everyone who tastes these eggs knows that they are so fresh and so healthy - the yolks are practically orange due to the healthy lives the chickens lead.

Along with our CSA program, we are lucky to live in an area where restaurants and grocery stores are carrying more local organic meats and other whole foods.

As I search for peace with my choice to eat meat, I have learned a few things. One: I still love a good steak. Two: I love meat even more if I know it came from a local farm where the animal had a healthy life. Three: I am confident that I can convince you to try meat again one day too.

Lindsey lives in Eastern Village Cohousing in Silver Spring, MD with her husband Brian, her 3 year old son, Caleb, and their pet chinchilla (rescue), Onion Head. She is a passionate omnivore, believes in balance, and would rather be biking, skiing, or hiking.

Print this post

6 Responses to “Ethics of a Jewish Carnivore: In Search of the Ideal Steak”

  1. Jackie Says:

    i’m sorry but why would we want to de-evolve and start eating meat again? To keep you company and make you feel better? I’m sorry you can’t picture the death of those cows you eat, not pretty and lots of agony. Your existence is not worth agony for any being.
    You could also read up on the effects on the environment that the meat and dairy industry is having including that it creates 18% of the greenhouse gases in the world, more than transportation according to a UN report along with the other giant problems of runoff.
    So too bad the door to opening wide your heart and empathy was opened for you and you chose to slam it shut. The rest of us will not be following you. And why would you want to convince them to eat meat again?

  2. Karen Says:

    I would love to get meat from my CSA, but none of it is kosher. I’ve toyed with the idea of bringing a shochet out to rural Texas, but the prospect is too much for little me. Glad you like your steak.

  3. Jeffrey Yoskowitz Says:

    Lindsey, I’m with you all the way, except for your last point, which was to convince others to do the same. I disagree with Jackie and the standard PETA line for many reasons, specifically because the fact that you’re getting your meat locally and responsibly raised means that your meat is not contributing to the greenhoues gas statistic so often quoted for industrial meat in this country. When will this argument stop being rehashed?

    Nevertheless, I disagree with many vegetarians because I feel they try and make me become one of them. Let’s just let people make their own socially conscious decisions and not proselytize. Good for you for thinking so hard about where your meat comes from and may we wish that all people think hard for THEMSELVES about what they put in their bodies.

  4. gormond Says:

    “Why should I be ashamed to eat meat?”

    Paying a company to torture an animal is shameful.

  5. lux Says:

    If Hashem wanted us to be vegetarians he would not have given us the laws of kashrut. Instead, he would simply have said that all meat was treif. He didn’t.

Leave a Reply

Peace Now

Join us for Hazon's Food Conference: Click here for more info

Advertise on The Jew & The Carrot