Jews Bring Too Much Food? Waste During Shiva

My mother and me in happier times

A few months ago I wrote some tips on appropriate and helpful ways to bring food to someone who’s ill or grieving.  At the time, my mother (that’s her in the picture, with me at our dining room table in happier times) was in treatment for terminal cancer, and though we were grateful to have an amazing community providing food for us during such a difficult time, I often found myself guiltily throwing out some leftovers that had gotten shoved to the back of the fridge to make room for new offerings.  I suggested that people try to bring smaller portions.

Then, on September 9th, my mother passed away, and what had been a slight excess of food transformed into a mountain of baked goods, stacks of trays from kosher restaurants, and Tupperware as far as the eye could see.  From the very first day of shiva we were completely overwhelmed with food, and the same women who were coordinating people to bring us meals were having to sort through the fridge and toss or freeze the obscene amount of casseroles, cakes and random snacks that people were bringing when they came to visit with us.

One of the rules of sitting shiva is that the mourners should not prepare their own food, so we had expected to have meals for the week made and prepared by others, but we were not prepared for the sheer quantity of what we ended up with.  Among other things, we ended the week with an ant problem in our kitchen because there was so much food sitting out all the time.

Over all, I found shiva to be a difficult but incredibly healing week, and it was wonderful to have so many people showing us their support in so many ways.  Still, it frustrates me to see so much food go to waste, and some of the craziness that resulted from having other people run my kitchen for a week was no fun at all.  So, here’s some new tips and thoughts on bringing food to a shiva house.

Tips after the jump!

Call ahead
Typically meals are arranged for a family sitting shiva, so if you want to contribute, it’s best to find out who’s coordinating the meals, and ask when you could sign up to bring something instead of just showing up with something at random.  Unplanned dishes are the ones that tend to end up in the compost heap first.

Plan (farther) ahead
It was a pretty huge shock to go from having so much food we didn’t know what to do with ourselves, to being all on our own as soon as shiva was over.  No one really did this, but it would have been so nice to have someone offer to bring us a meal a week after shiva ended, or even two weeks later.  This could have significantly cut down on the waste, too.

Be aware of kitchen etiquette
If you’re going to be bringing food or helping out at a shiva house, try to be respectful of the kitchen you’re dealing with, and if you don’t know, please ask.  At one point during the week my sister walked into our kitchen to find that someone had taken a sharpie to our Dairy drainer and carefully labeled it ‘MEAT.’  A few days later I noticed that the bin we usually use to store potatoes contained a 9×13 pan, some measuring cups, some silverware, a paring knife, and a sauce pan.  Though we only left the house once the entire week, no one who was involved in dealing with the kitchen ever came to us to ask where something belonged, or if something was meat or dairy.  When the shiva was over, the amount of reorganizing we had to do was really epic.

Consider a healthy treat
If you really want to bring something unsolicited, consider something homemade and healthy.  By far the majority of the food that we received was some variety of baked goods.  Now don’t get me wrong, I love cake, and I love bagels, but at a certain point it was just out of control, and in the end, many cakes were tossed half-eaten.  Some people opted to bring more unusual and healthier offerings, and those tended to get gobbled up because we were feeling a little overwhelmed by how much sugar we were all consuming.  When a friend brought over homemade guacamole before Shabbat, it went quickly. We loved the fancy cappuccino torte and the vegan mango cheesecake was delicious, but every once in a while I just wanted a carrot.

Share a food memory
If someone from the family indicates that they want to talk, consider sharing a food-related memory.  I know how uncomfortable people get at shiva houses.  It is sad, and can be awkward to try to express sympathy without resorting to clichés.  But food can be a great vehicle to beginning a conversation about the deceased.  I was so touched by the number of people who mentioned wonderful Shabbat and holiday meals they had with my mother.  People told us about being new in town, and how my mother invited them to eat with our family.  They remembered specific dishes she was famous for, and told us about times she brought food to them when they needed support.  Those conversations were incredibly meaningful and always so nice to hear; a great improvement over “I’m so sorry for your loss.”

Losing my mother was harder than anything I could have imagined, but already I feel like I’ve learned so much from this loss.  I wish I didn’t know this stuff, but I hope now I can be more helpful and supportive to my friends when they’re in need.

My sisters and I put together a cookbook for our mother on Mother’s Day.  You can buy our cookbook, Vixens in the Kitchen at  For every copy we sell, Tastebook donates $10 to breast cancer research.

Print This Post Print This Post

6 Responses to “Jews Bring Too Much Food? Waste During Shiva”

  1. Alix Says:

    I just buried my 98-year-old grandpa today (who I wrote about in an earlier post), and came home to find yours. I am so sorry for your loss; your second to last paragraph really resonated for me, as I felt exactly the same way when I lost my mom six years ago, also to breast cancer. I know it’s cliched, but time does help. It will get easier, but you will never stop missing her. I still hope to meet you some day.

  2. Ron Says:

    In our locale, the local homeless shelter is always happy to get donations of food. YMMV, of course.

    It’s also something for “doer-type” people who want to help and don’t know what else to do — make up a nice box and run it over to the shelter.

  3. phyllis Says:

    our congregation has a person who contacts each shiva house at the end and offers to take any leftovers to a local shelter. people love this – it makes them feel like the food isn’t going to waste…

  4. Tools & Home Improvement Says:

    I liked up to you will obtain performed proper here. The comic strip is attractive, your authored material stylish. nevertheless, you command get bought an nervousness over that you want be delivering the following. in poor health no doubt come more formerly once more since exactly the same just about very regularly within case you shield this increase.

  5. black charger splitter holder Says:

    I believe everything typed was actually very logical. However, what about this?
    what if you were to create a awesome title?

    I ain’t suggesting your information isn’t good., however suppose you added a title to maybe get
    folk’s attention? I mean The Jew and the Carrot Blog Archive
    Jews Bring Too Much Food? Waste During Shiva – Voice of the New Jewish Food Movement is kinda boring.
    You should glance at Yahoo’s home page and see how they
    create article titles to get people to open the links.
    You might add a related video or a related pic or two
    to grab people interested about everything’ve got to say.
    In my opinion, it could bring your posts a little livelier.

  6. Andree Peha Says:

    Thank you for sharing this fantastic data. I am usually looking for new and fascinating approaches to improve my company techniques.

Leave a Reply