Mandel

Local food for Tu B’Shevat?

We’ve gotten a lot of calls at the office these past few days of people asking:
Do you know where I can get local organic food for Tu B’Shevat?

This is, of course, exciting that people think to call Hazon to ask these things, and that people are thinking about these things in the first place.

It’s problematic, though. Tu B’Shevat is February 3rd. That is, a globally-warmed season aside, quite squarely in the middle of the winter for most American Jews.

What, then, are our options?

In New York, and I assume elsewhere, there are farmers markets that are open year round. You can buy root vegetables (harvested in the fall and stored in root cellars) such as carrots, potatoes, onions, and squashes with relative ease. Apples and some pears (also in storage) are abundant. And many farmers have greenhouses or hoop houses where they can grow green things during the winter: kale, spinach, salad greens—there’s one stand at Union Square Farmers Market that sells cherry tomatoes from their greenhouse, year round.

Ok great. But on Tu B’Shevat, we eat fruits and nuts that grow in the land of Israel. Read: Mediterranean climate. Texas and California shouldn’t have too much trouble finding local nuts this time of year…. But not so much in the Northeast. So we have two, somewhat contradictory options:

Option One: Dried fruit. There are plenty of local peaches, apricots, plums (for the second world, where we eat fruits with a soft exterior and hard interior), and grapes, raisins and berries (think craisins) that can be used for the third world (all soft) that are ripe in the summer around here, and which can be dried for eating year round. Maybe it’s something you might even want to try next summer; cut your fruit into thin slices and use a convection oven, food dehydrator, or simply leave them out in the sun to dry, and save for next year’s Tu B’Shevat. Local fruit in the middle of winter - that’s one option.

Option Two: Tu B’Shevat is not the time for local. You can celebrate any number of different things on Tu B’Shevat, from mysticism to feminism, but the main thrust of the holiday is trees, agriculture, and the land of Israel. It is quite remarkable how eating food from another place can transport us to that place: sugar dates, pomegranates, almonds… with every bite we are closer and closer to lounging at the Dead Sea. This is a good thing. It’s a question of kodesh and chol, of what we do on ordinary days and what we do on special days. If you’re looking to make your Tu B’Shevat seder unique – buy fruit from Israel. Seek it out! If your grocery store doesn’t tell you where the fruit comes from, ask the people who work there. Chances are you’ll find peppers or fresh citrus from Israel; you’ll certainly be able to find canned olives.

And then, eat local the rest of the month. Celebrations mean doing something different than what you normally do. It’s OK, once in a while, to enjoy food that comes from far away; indeed, the spice trade and the search for delicacies from around the world is what prompted global expansion. Not necessarily a bad thing. If you eat mostly local foods from now until Tu B’Shevat, and into the lean months of early spring…go right ahead and indulge in foreign treats – it’ll make the holiday special.

(at our Tu B’Shevat Seder at the JCC on February 3rd, we’ll be serving root vegetable Terra Chips, and fruits from Israel :-)  Register today!)

Print this post

3 Responses to “Local food for Tu B’Shevat?”

  1. zed Says:

    I am rather new to these festivals, but as a serious fruit-grower (both hobby and small-time commercial/organic), I am really getting “in” to the festivals that have connections to agriculture, and especially fruit.

    I grow in a (mostly) Mediterranean climate. And, while I don’t (yet) know much about the history of Tu B’Shevat and its fruit traditions, I can’t imagine that it would historically have been meant to be celebrated with fresh fruits–at least not the ones you mention. Even with our long growing seasons out here in southern California, there is not much fresh and local fruit this time of year even in a northern-hemisphere Mediterranean climate. (Nor nuts, as they would have been harvested the previous growing season.)

    We can harvest some apples (like Granny Smith and Pink Lady) into January or even February (though not this year, with the freeze). And, of course, citrus season is in full swing. But not pears, pomegranates, or much of anything else. So, it would have to be fruit that was either in storage (apples, pears, and others that keep well under proper conditions) or fruits preserved in various ways.

  2. Aliza Says:

    Yes, it is interesting that Tu B’shevat has morphed into this holiday of “fruit,” when actually Sukkot is the holiday that specifically celebrates the harvest, where the idea of local would seem more important. There is an interesting role for us to play in celebrating Tu B’shevat as diaspora Jews who may be conscious of some of the complex issues relating to the environment and fruit-bearing trees in Israel and surrounding areas…perhaps this should be the topic of our forthcoming Tu B’shevat seders, rather than ONLY celebrating the traditional fruit varieties which are more historical at this point.

  3. Rabbi Shmuel Says:

    it is the Rosh Hashana of tres however and the maples are getting ready:)

Leave a Reply

Peace Now

Join us for Hazon's Food Conference: Click here for more info

Advertise on The Jew & The Carrot