drisha

Michael Pollan for Secretary of Agriculture?

farm4.jpg

Yesterday, I found the following “Action Alert” in my inbox:

MICHAEL POLLAN for U.S. SECRETARY OF AGRICULTURE
WHAT: Get Pollan appointed United States Secretary of Agriculture
WHEN: Immediately
HOW: Through our U.S. Representatives and Senators

MY RESPONSE: WTF??!

Over the last couple of weeks, there have been lots of wistful twitterings from within the food movement about getting Michael Pollan (the watershed journalist and author of The Omnivore’s Dilemma and In Defense of Food) appointed as Barack Obama’s Secretary of Agriculture.  But this was the first time I’d seen an actual, serious  – or pseudo-serious – call to action around the idea.

My first thought, with all due respect, was, “What are my fellow foodie friends thinking?”  Yes, Pollan is one of the most significant thinkers and writers about sustainable eating today – even a food hero.  But he has said many times before, including during an interview with this blog, that he does not have any interest in being a spokesperson, let alone a policy maker, for the food movement.  “I’m trying very hard to preserve my role as a journalist, and I’m not advocating a specific set of policies,” he said.

And according to an article printed in the San Francisco Gate, Pollan is (gasp) maybe even moving on a little bit from the whole food business:  “‘My wife says it’s time for me to move on,’” the UC Berkeley journalism professor and reluctant leader of the real food movement told The Chronicle. “If you had to listen to our dinner table conversation for the last five years, as she and my son do, you might be up for a new topic.’”

pollanindirt.jpgSo it would seem that the enthusiasm from the food movement in calling for Pollan as Ag Secretary probably has very little to do with what Pollan himself wants from his career path.  He is, after all, just a journalist.

But the very idea that a journalist might – even for a moment – be considered someone worthy of such an important political appointment, is incredibly significant.  Over the last few years, Michael Pollan has arguably shifted the conversation around food and sustainable agriculture in this country more than any policy maker.

That people throw around phrases like “rip up your lawn” (to grow vegetables, of course), or talk about the idea of the US Farm Bill as the “Food Bill” (because it impacts all eaters, not just farmers) is very much due to Pollan’s work.  Yesterday’s op-ed in the NY Times by Nicolas Kristof, urges the Obama administration to appoint a “Secretary of Food” instead of a Secretary of Agriculture,” for the same reason.  And who is quoted in the article as the chief expert on such things?  Yep, Pollan.  How could you not want this guy representing your dinner?

On second consideration, my guess – and hope – is that my fellow foodies are not serious in their suggestion that Michael Pollan be appointed to a position he has no interest in taking.  My guess is that they’re hoping to use the Action Alert campaign to raise awareness within the Senate and House that it is time to appoint a Secretary who has a “Pollan-slanted outlook” – one that cares about people and the planet as much as profit.  Someone who looks to the future and sees more organic family farmers and fewer cases of obesity-related diabetes, instead of more CAFOs and subsidies for high fructose corn syrup.

Here’s hoping they get what they want.

Print This Post Print This Post

5 Responses to “Michael Pollan for Secretary of Agriculture?”

  1. Avigail Says:

    It makes me wonder who Michael Pollan would support for the appointment…does anyone know?

  2. aliza Says:

    but they are going about it in an immature, unstrategic way and are detracting from the actual effort being organized around real candidates for USDA positions with “pollan-slanted outlooks” at http://www.fooddemocracynow.org

  3. Melinda Says:

    In isolation I’ve found the whole thing a little puzzling, for reasons you’ve outlined, but I think that we’ve got growing numbers of more informed food consumers and they’re starting to making their voices heard. Add to that the increasing urbanization of the US and the very urban orientation of the Democratic Party (I was particularly disheartened by some of the classist and anti-rural stuff that was said during the primaries), and there’s now this new group that wants representation and who feel that Michael Pollan can do that. The idea of affluent urban foodies setting US food policy doesn’t really give me the warm fuzzies.

  4. Joel Says:

    The Secretary of Agriculture is an appointment extensively influenced by the immediate communities who are regulated by the Agriculture department: the major food associations, food processors, growers, and the markets. It has most to do with farm subsidies and items included in the “farm bill” and I expect an individual who is otherwise unknown to the general public to be chosen for this job, or someone who is known to the public but has extensive ties to the industry itself. The Sec Agriculture is the main connection to the farm belt/food companies, the Sec Interior is connection to the Western states, the Treasury Sec is connection to NYC financial firms.

  5. Bobbi Says:

    Better that Michael Pollan remains a journalist and prophet. He’s more effective that way. Politicians need prophets to keep them honest and on track. We need people with vision.

Leave a Reply

hartman

harvest



Advertise on The Jew & The Carrot