Yid.Dish: Potato Salad, and Everyone Loves a Loophole

potato salad

As a high school student at my Jewish Day School, I fancied myself a little rebel. Pajama pants beneath long skirts. Adidas in spite of the no-sneakers dress code. Briefly, a safety pin in one ear. (My parents loved that.) I wasn’t the only one –- with the safety pin, OK, yes, but my friends dressed similarly –- yet rarely, if ever, did these infractions cause trouble. “You got away with murder,” my mother recalls, with admiration. “You and your friends.”

We did. I think the reason – aside from being nice girls from good families – is because we respected the letter of the law, but found our own way around it. In other words, we constantly searched for loopholes — a word that Merriam-Webster defines as “a means of escape, especially : an ambiguity or omission in the text through which the intent of a statute, contract, or obligation may be evaded.” (I also like, and did not know until this posting, that loophole can mean “a small opening through which small arms may be fired.”)

In my adult life, my interest in Judaic loopholes has found expression through my obsession with dishes that Taste As Though They’re Traif, or Should Be. Given the glut of vegan butters on the market, Smart Balance among them, the number of those recipes has increased exponentially. And you should have seen the day when I learned that quinoa is kosher for Pesach.

I also must be honest and admit that part of the food + loophole business stems from observing my mother’s confusion in her kosher kitchen. She is a terrific cook, but because she converted shortly before I was born, she didn’t have experience cooking per Orthodox law. So in the early days, she was plagued with questions: How do you make mashed potatoes, meant to accompany a meat meal, taste good and creamy without milk or butter? (Chicken stock, mayo, paprika, salt and pepper.) Is it possible to cook palatable split-pea soup without the ham hocks? (Yes; see the Barefoot Contessa version for proof.)

In the spirit of the loophole – and summer! – I’d like to share a recipe for a side dish you can bring to a meat barbecue. Guests who wish only to eat meat or parve dishes can enjoy them, and no one will notice what’s missing.

Adapted from the Barefoot Contessa Cookbook

* A few pounds red potatoes (the regular-sized ones are fine)
* 2 tbs Champagne vinegar
* 2 tbs vegetable stock
* 3 tbs dry white wine
* 2 tbs mustard
* Bunch of fresh dill
* Basil, if you have a fresh bunch on hand
* 10 tbs good olive oil
* one bunch scallions
* a couple handfuls snap peas

Boil the potatoes. Drain before they get too mushy. Chop roughly. In a large bowl, toss with white wine and vegetable stock while the potatoes are still warm.

Mix the remaining wet ingredients as you would any dressing; pour over the potatoes. Chop up the scallions, snap peas, dill, and basil, if you have it. Add salt and pepper to taste.

Print This Post Print This Post

2 Responses to “Yid.Dish: Potato Salad, and Everyone Loves a Loophole”

  1. Delilah Says:

    Sounds delicious. I definitely have to get some champagne vinegar into my pantry!

  2. The Shmethicist Says:

    An added bonus of this recipe: it also won’t give you (and your guests) food poisoning if it sits out in the sun for hours, as does all the food at our neighborhood 4th of July block party. Indeed, this year, my sweetie made his usual contribution, deviled eggs, with olive oil instead of mayo, for that very reason. It turns out the olive oil version were just as yummy (really, everyone said so, not just me), and healthier to boot.

    Loophole? Or radical innovation? You be the judge.

    (Speaking of loopholes, I did combine the uneaten veggie “not dogs” from yesterday with some leftover pea soup from earlier in the week, and though I am no Contessa, it made for a scrumptious—and barefoot—dinner tonight. Generally I avoid fake meat, which is probably too overprocessed to be good for me or the planet, but it is a nice occasional to concession to the carnivore who’s shared my heart and home for so many years)

Leave a Reply